Graham Trophy was first presented in 1968 by George W. Graham, club member 1954-1975, to be awarded to winning rink of men's senior skips Wednesday night league curling. The Maxwell Trophy preceeded the Graham, it was first presented in 1956 by SCC member Howard Maxwell, also awarded to winning ring of senior skips' Wednesday night scheduled curling.
| Year | Skip | Vice-Skip | Second | Lead |
| 2017 | J. Stopera | J. Meinhold | D. Dial | T. Eager |
| 2016 | ||||
| 2015 | ||||
| 2014 | ||||
| 2013 | ||||
| 2012 | ||||
| 2011 | ||||
| 2010 | ||||
| 2009 | ||||
| 2008 | ||||
| 2007 | ||||
| 2006 | V. Temple | V. Rodriguez | J. Crawford | W. Ralston |
| 2005 | J. Stopera Jr. | J. Campbell | V. Rodriquez | J. Lisuzzo |
| 2004 | L. Cathers | D. Quinn | J. Mayott | F. Mackintosh |
| 2003 | R. Mulig | D. Spencer | M. Durant | K. Sheedy |
| 2002 | J. Sinkins | D. Spring | D. Hooper | B. Severenko |
| 2001 | not awarded: two teams tied, no playoff | |||
| 2000 | R. Travis | P. Sheehan | C. Becker | E. Hanna |
| 1999 | J. Fitzgerald | F. Freedman | W. Walraed | M. Leno |
| 1998 | J. Fitzgerald | M. Zavadil | E. Hanna | W. Dever |
| 1997 | J. Sinkins | R. Mulig | B. Segel | E. Hanna |
| 1996 | R. Mulig | J. Cleveland | M. Culligan | D. Berger |
| 1995 | J. Stopera Jr. | D. Stopera | J. Pelerin | E. LaPine |
| 1994 | J. Stopera Sr. | J. Fitzgerald | J. Sinkins | E. Hanna/E. LanPine |
| 1993 | M. Erdman | R. Munro | G. Erdman | K. Munro |
| 1992 | R. Fink | M. Mount | R. Hanna | D. Beeler |
| 1991 | J. Stopera Jr. | D. Stopera | T. Pearson | D. Spring |
| 1990 | R. Mulig | R. Chick | D. Spencer | P. Clark |
| 1989 | R. Mulig | D. Spencer | T. Andres | P. Clark |
| 1988 | R. Fink | D. Fink | P. O'Malley | T. Holland |
| 1987 | R. Fink | D. Fink | P. O'Malley | T. Holland |
| 1986 | R. Fink | D. Fink | D. Clements | P. Kirwan |
| 1985 | J. Stopera Jr. | T. Pearson | R. Sullivan | J. Duguid |
| 1984 | J. Stopera Jr. | T. Pearson | R. Sullivan | J. Duguid |
| 1983 | C. Hequembourg | R. Fink | T. Getty Jr. | P. O'Malley |
| 1982 | W. Millington | H. Lang | W. Niedrach | G. Thompson |
| 1981 | C. Hequembourg | R. Fink | P. O'Malley | J. Stopera Jr. |
| 1980 | C. Hequembourg | R. Fink | P. O'Malley | J. Stopera Jr. |
| 1979 | R. Neuber | R. Gill | J. Holmblad | A. Van de Car |
| 1978 | O. Wifladt | T. Girard | H. Cassidy | W. Szymaszek |
| 1977 | D. Spencer | R. Mulig | J. Gleeson | A. Bates |
| 1976 | D. Beeler | N. Schell | M. Thompson Sr. | E. Fronko |
| 1975 | C. Hequembourg | A.W. Millington | J.P. Link | E.W. Snyder |
| 1974 | C. Hequembourg | A.W. Millington | J.P. Link | E.W. Snyder |
| 1973 | F. Morhous | J. Cary | W. Glindmyer | J. McNaughton |
| 1972 | C. Hequembourg | R.A. Neuber | E. Snyder | D. Groetch |
| 1971 | C. Hequembourg | J.E. Link | W.C. Lutes | E.W. Snyder |
| 1970 | W.A. Salvini | J.E. Downs | J.O. Burns | T. Barrie |
| 1969 | J.E. Collins | O. Wifladt | L.B. VanDyck | E.H. Gabel |
| 1968 | ||||
| 1967 | F.W. Hequembourg | A. Wood | C. Hequembourg | L. Reid |
| 1966 | H.M. Van de Car | E. Cabaniss | L. McNeil | J. Van de Car |
| 1965 | G. Graham | F. Straight | J. Cortesi | H. Curran |
| 1964 | J. Link | R. Woodruff | J. Peters | R. Girard |
| 1963 | F. Cermak | T. Ryan | E. Fink | T. Lewkowicz |
| 1962 | H.M. Van de Car | C.C. Hutton | D.S. McNab | F.E. Morhous |
| 1961 | J.S. Cary | R.A. Neuber | R.B. Ostrander | A. Duguid |
| 1960 | A. Nitchman | D. McNab | T. Lewjowicz | J. McNaughton |
| 1959 | F. Cermak | E. Corrado | E. Fink | T. Mason |
| 1958 | T. Thomas | H. Parker | J. Link | W. Rankin |
| 1957 | A. Swick | R. Crawford | J. Link | G. Graham |
| 1956 | J. Lotridge | F. Cermak | O.B. Nye | T. Ryan |
